Last Call for the European Car? Acea and Clepa’s warning cry

The European automobile industry has never been as threatened as it is today. The cause is not Chinese competition or other external factors, but rather decisions made in Brussels. On paper and in the ideas of the European Union, it all seemed straightforward: in 2019, the EU decided to put an end to internal combustion engine cars by 2035. In addition to imposing unprecedented changes in just 16 years on an industry employing 13 million people, the European Union added a series of restrictions from 2025 to 2030 regarding emissions which could collectively result in fines of up to €15 billion. While initially all European car manufacturers welcomed the news positively, in many cases foreseeing the end of thermal vehicle production by 2030, today the situation has completely changed, putting at risk a sector that currently accounts for 7% of all jobs and 8% of the GDP of the entire European Union.
Sustainable Transition
Acea and Clepa, the associations of European automobile manufacturers and aftermarket suppliers, sent a lengthy letter at the end of August to President Von der Leyen and the European Commission, requesting an open dialogue and a realistic revision of targets with a significant change of course. “As car manufacturers and suppliers, we are committed to helping the European Union achieve its goal of zero emissions by 2050. Together, we have launched hundreds of new electric vehicle models and pledged to invest over €250 billion to support the green transition by 2030. We want this transition to succeed, but we are frustrated by the lack of a pragmatic political vision. The EU currently regulates manufacturers in terms of supplying new vehicles but fails to create the conditions to enable the transition. Europe faces an almost total dependence on Asia as far as batteries are concerned, an uneven distribution of charging infrastructure, higher production costs, including electricity prices, and burdensome tariffs from key trading partners, such as the 15% duty on EU vehicle exports to the United States.” With these words, Ola Källenius, President of Acea and CEO of Mercedes Benz, and Matthias Zink, President of Clepa and CEO of Powertrain and Chassis at Schaeffler, have sounded a warning cry that should put the European Commission before the true situation of the European automotive industry. The warning has come not only from the two associations but also from a long list of CEOs of European car manufacturers, all agreeing that electric vehicles alone cannot be the only way forward.

Unattainable Targets
As highlighted by the two associations, achieving the strict CO2 targets for cars and vans for 2030 and 2035 in today’s world is no longer possible. Instead, it is necessary to review the current course of carbon dioxide reduction in road transport to guarantee the achievement of climate objectives, while also safeguarding Europe’s industrial competitiveness, social cohesion, and the strategic resilience of its supply chains. Because beyond the reduced new vehicle sales, the crisis is also hitting component suppliers hard, with a situation worse than that seen in 2008. All this comes alongside ever-ageing vehicles, with the average age rising from 7 to 12 years.
The Importance of Technological Neutrality
How, if at all possible, can the European automotive industry be restored to its rightful role? The two associations emphasise the importance of technological neutrality as a fundamental principle, paving the way for plug-in hybrids, range extender cars, highly efficient internal combustion vehicles, hydrogen, and decarbonised fuels. Added to this they call for subsidies to boost the sluggish sales of electric models, growth in charging infrastructure, lower energy costs, streamlined bureaucracy, and the conditions for smart investment along the value chains of batteries, semiconductors, and critical raw materials. The ultimate goal is to unite environmental sustainability with economic and social sustainability.
Internal Combustion Engines Until 2050
“Full electric vehicles are not the only solution: we need to examine the challenges of the energy transition with greater realism, adopting a technologically neutral approach,” says Mauro Severi, president of Aica (Italian Association of Garage Equipment Manufacturers). “The architecture of policies for the energy transition must be reviewed. As is well known, the fines and bans imposed by the European Union have caused serious harm to the entire continental car supply chain, including component manufacturers and equipment suppliers. No one else in the world has adopted policies even remotely similar to Europe to contain CO2 emissions. The 2035 deadline for the end of the internal combustion engine, with its related repercussions, should be moved to 2050 to give the European economy room to breathe and the opportunity to rationally address the problem of polluting emissions.”