Cars of the future? Not just electric

Borrowing from Mark Twain, we can say that the loud proclamations of the death of the endothermic engine seem “grossly exaggerated”. In fact, the rather unflattering sales of electric vehicles in the marketplace suggests that ICE unit has not yet run its course and may well be one of the solutions that will contribute to the much sought-after decarbonisation of transport. How and why, this could happen, was the subject of a wide-ranging discussion on the evolution of the automobile at Next Generation Mobility 2024, an event dedicated to the mobility of today and tomorrow held in Turin on 18 and 19 September.
Electric market lacking “power”
There is no doubt that the electric vehicle market needs a shake-up. Despite the European Union's strict guidelines and the commitment of manufacturers, market results are far from encouraging: in the first eight months of 2024, new EV registrations in Europe fell by almost 44% (data: Acea - European Automobile Manufacturers Association). This slowdown clashes with the intentions of the European government, which on the one hand is pushing full speed ahead towards the electric transition with increasingly ambitious and stringent targets - in 2025, the maximum average CO2 emissions limit for new vehicles will fall from 116 grams/km of CO2 today to 93.6 grams/km - but on the other hand it seems unwilling to revive incentives in support the the industrial transition.
At the beginning of September, Luca de Meo, CEO of Renault and President of Acea, sounded the alarm: if the market trend for electric vehicles continues as it is today, the European automotive industry may have to pay fines of up to 15 billion euro or cut production by more than 2.5 million vehicles by 2025. Unfortunately, the forecasts are far from positive. The global market for electric vehicles is growing - an estimated 89 million units will be sold in 2024 - but the main driver is China. In Europe and North America, growth appears to be stagnating. “The Green Deal sets a target of an 87 per cent market share for electric vehicles by 2035, but we believe that without appropriate incentives, it will not go over 50 per cent," Emanuele Cordone, Director of Automotive and Industrial at AlixPartners, told Next Generation Mobility. Since 2019, this consulting agency has been analysing the propensity to buy EVs in different markets.
The results confirm the forecast: "In China, figures have risen over time, with 97% of respondents saying they would like to buy an electric vehicle. In Europe and the US, on the other hand, the curve is flat, with the percentages stagnating at 43% and 35% respectively”. Beyond the stated intentions, the market data, as already mentioned, confirm a progressive lack of interest in Western markets. Price is a major factor in the decision not to buy. “The delta between electric and thermal is 45% in Europe and 52% in the US, while in China it is only a few percentage points - says Cordone. In Europe, the lack of a solid recharging infrastructure is also proving to be a barrier”.
Revenge of the endothermic
In the chasm between what is ideal and reality, combustion engines still maintain a relevant place. “The advantage is that this is an established technology. So, in this exploration phase, many manufacturers are choosing to start with what already exists, i.e. diesel or natural gas engines, and adapt them with small modifications to run on hydrogen,” explains Federico Millo, professor at the Politecnico di Torino. Hydrogen internal combustion appears to be a more than viable option: it offers similar performance to the diesel engine, producing only water vapour, with lower operating costs than the fuel cell. “Critical issues such as the lack of infrastructure can be overcome relatively easily in specific applications such as public transport fleets or heavy transport vehicles. This technology does not provide a single, universal answer in favour of decarbonisation," he continued, "but it can be an important building block. On the other hand, relying on a single technological option is short-sighted. In fact, we cannot limit ourselves to looking at CO2 emissions stemming only from the fuel tank to the wheels. We need to look at the entire life cycle of an electric vehicle, including charging. The fastest and most effective way is therefore to make the most of the available technology mix”.

Kpmg's forecast for 2050 suggests that the market will be evenly split between internal combustion, hybrid, electric and fuel cell. “Half of the market will still be thermal," says Piersandro Trevisan, development consultant for the Lombardia Mobility Cluster. The Lombardia Region, shares the environmental sustainability objectives set by the European Union but is committed to the principle of “technological neutrality”, and has commissioned a study by the Mobility Cluster to explore alternative solutions to electric vehicles. “The fuels of the future will have to be renewable and without net CO2 emissions - explains Trevisan. The ICE endothermic engine will continue to play a fundamental role in terms of cost and reliability, but it will have to adapt to the characteristics of the new fuels, improving efficiency and reducing emissions. Engine and fuels will also need to be more integrated in terms of technology and components”.
Sustainability has many facets
A car can be sustainable in many ways, even beyond what is found under the bonnet. Despite poor sales figures, manufacturers are very active in areas such as circular economy. The automotive sector (and not only) is very much oriented towards material flow management in a closed loop - confirms Marco Capellini, CEO of Matrec. After a slight slowdown five or six years ago, companies have resumed research into the recovery, recycling and reuse of materials”. There is no lack of evidence. Audi, for example, is working with 15 partners on the MaterialLoop project, which is exploring the possibilities of reusing materials and components from end-of-life vehicles. A year ago, Stellantis signed a joint venture agreement with Galloo, a company specialising in metal recycling, to recover end-of-life vehicles from their last owners and reclaim several components for reuse, regeneration and recycling. Meanwhile, at its historic Mirafiori plant in Torino, the group activated Sustainera, a 73,000 square metre centre focused on the regeneration of used vehicles and the recovery and reuse of materials and components. “In the tyre sector, more and more companies are investing in the reuse of recycled powder," Capellini quoted, adding, "this has both economic and environmental benefits and, interesting business opportunities are developing around this type of activity. It is now convenient for manufacturers to own their own materials and outsource the transformation process to counteract fluctuations in the price of raw materials”.
The market, both upstream and downstream, is no longer reluctant to choose a remanufactured product, which is now increasingly similar to new ones. On the other hand, the way has been paved. The European Commission's Directive 2000/53 requires vehicle and equipment manufacturers to take into account the dismantling, reuse and recovery of vehicle parts right from the design stage by ensuring that at least 85% by weight is reusable and/or recyclable and at least 95% by weight is reusable and/or recoverable (Article 4). The supply chain is working to achieve these targets, but there is still some way to go, as Anselmo Calò, President of Ada (National Association of Car Wreckers), pointed out in his speech: "In 2022, more than 870 thousand vehicles were scrapped, representing more than 1 million tonnes of material. Of this, 72.5% was recovered and recycled”.
In anticipation of a future that will be as "electrically driven" as possible, thinking about the sustainability of the automotive supply chain cannot ignore one of its most problematic elements: batteries. This is certainly the case in the European Union, which, by means of Regulation 2023/1542, has made it compulsory from February 2027 for vehicle batteries and industrial batteries with a capacity of more than 2 kWh to have a digital passport. This is an electronic document containing static data (e.g. production date, cell material, etc.) as well as dynamic data, i.e. parameters that vary according to the use of the product. The aim is to ensure transparency and sustainability in the battery value chain. “Today, information about a vehicle's battery is uncertain”, explains Luca Gastaldo, Sales Manager Mobility Connected Services at Bosch: “we don't know how long it will last, how it will behave and what problems it might have in the future”. To tackle this issue, Bosch came up with the service “Battery in the Cloud”: “It's our digital twin concept of the battery. It allows us to keep an eye on the battery's life, stress factors, degradation, detect anomalies and certify its conditions”.
Cars in the near future
As the industry evolves, innovation will play a crucial role in making cars more sustainable, safer and the overall user experience more engaging. In his thought-provoking speech at Next Generation Mobility 2024, Davide Zane, Business Development Director at Sketchin, talked about how artificial intelligence and so-called “immersive” technologies are helping to imagine possible futures in which people will have truly unprecedented experiences. “In the not-too-distant future, instead of talking to different apps and devices, we will have a “digital butler” with whom we will communicate in a natural way and who will manage all the apps and multiple service agents”. As an example of an automotive application, Zane mentioned the “efficiency assistant”, a digital assistant that supports productivity by providing operational guidance and help in identifying anomalies: “It is like having a colleague by your side who can communicate and interact with different devices and process very different data," said Zane. This is a fitting introduction to the “vehicle assistant”, a personal assistant that follows us around in whatever vehicle we are driving, helping us to use the vehicle more efficiently. “The assistant could compare personal and weather data to determine the best mobility solution, suggesting, for example, that on a sunny day we take public transport or cycle instead of driving because it is more convenient or sustainable”.

Finally, an often neglected but crucial chapter is aerodynamics: "a great opportunity for innovation," said Alessandro Ferraris, co-founder and CEO of Beond, a Torino Polytechnic institute spin-off that provides advanced engineering services specifically for the transport sector. “Aerodynamics is not just a technical phenomenon or an algorithm," explained Ferraris. “Improving the aerodynamics of a vehicle affects its design and has a tangible impact on its behaviour in terms of performance, safety and energy efficiency”.